PIs Working in the Interest of Victims of Medical Malpractice… and Doctors Faced with Frivolous Lawsuits

Medical Malpractice Claim on a tableWe could all imagine it happening to us: You go into a laparoscopic surgical clinic for a routine outpatient procedure and you end up with a severe infection due to provable negligence that leaves you laid up for months and unable to work. What was going to be something quick, easy, and necessary becomes the cause of all new financial problems that are bound to leave you destitute.

This is what medical malpractice looks like, and this is exactly how much of an impact it can have on people’s lives.

Faced with the frightening prospect of mounting a medical malpractice lawsuit against a wealthy doctor or major hospital system – and the legal teams they keep on retainer for just these kinds of situations – more and more people are forced to hire private investigators that specialize in uncovering facts and proving fault in medical malpractice suits.

According to CSU Fresno, 2019 the most common sources of medical malpractice claims from 2013 to 2017 were diagnostic errors. 

A study conducted in John Hopkins Medicine stated that 250,000 deaths annually happen because of medical errors. 

Sponsored Content

To fully understand the gravity of medical malpractice in the United States and the escalating need for medical malpractice investigators, consider these sobering facts from the Medical Malpractice Center:

  • The 3rd leading cause of death in the US is medical negligence.
  • Erroneous diagnosis results in 80,000 to 100,000 deaths annually in the US.
  • Every year there are roughly 15,000 to 19,000 medical malpractice suits filed in the US.
  • 80% of all medical malpractice lawsuits that land in court result in no payouts.
  • 1 out of every 3 patients will fall victim to a medical error during their hospitalization.

Private investigators hoping to break into the challenging world of medical malpractice need plenty of preparation.

Gaining widespread knowledge and experience in these fields will help solidify your competency and attract the eye of future employers:

Obtaining a Certified Legal Investigator (CLI) certificate from the National Association of Legal Investigators will help give your résumé the final punch to the top.

Why People Hire Medical Malpractice Investigators

We live in a time when medical malpractice is almost as common as frivolous lawsuits aimed at medical staff simply trying to do. 

It is a common myth that people have started to believe in which is that these medical errors are rare. But here’s a startling fact: according to the Institute of Medicine, each year between 44,000 and 98,000 Americans die in hospitals due to preventable medical errors, compared to only 43,000 who die in car accidents.

In most cases, a person, company, or government agency will hire medical malpractice investigator over suspicion that a healthcare worker has committed an error that resulted in avoidable harm, injury, or death. Entire medical facilities or medical staff teams can also stand accused of malpractice.

Although not as common, hospitals or healthcare workers accused of medical malpractice will hire medical private investigators to discredit claims against them. For example:

  • In 2005, the Legal Support Investigative Service was hired by a doctor accused of medical malpractice after a former patient claimed loss of function in her right arm after surgery. Through surveillance footage, investigators exhibited the plaintiff’s unhindered use of her right arm, rendering the claim unequivocally baseless.

Both sides of medical malpractice disputes may also hire medical malpractice investigators as a preliminary step before filing an insurance claim, civil lawsuit, or criminal lawsuit.

Sponsored Content

Legal suits are particularly expensive. Plaintiffs are responsible for paying court filing fees, compensating expert witnesses, and procuring medical records. And even if they do win their case, a substantial percentage is typically absorbed by attorney contingency fees.

As a result, most people will hire medical malpractice investigators because it’s more cost-effective than hiring an attorney. By determining the legitimacy of a client’s medical malpractice dispute investigators will either:

  • Provide evidentiary credibility of medical malpractice thereby supporting impending or pending insurance claims or legal suits.


  • Find insubstantial proof of medical malpractice thereby discouraging the pursuit of further legal action.

Attorneys themselves may also hire a medical malpractice investigator as part of their litigation team in order to save time and money during pending lawsuits.

The Many Faces of Medical Malpractice

A hard-hitting medical investigator does not just find evidence that a medical error happened. They uncover which medical error happened. Since medical malpractice can happen at any stage of the patient experience, pinning down the exact error can be arduous.

As per various reports, medical malpractice claims can be broken down by type: 33% diagnosis errors, 23% surgical errors, 18% treatment problems, 10% obstetrics, and 10% anesthesia or medication errors.

According to Private Investigator Info, the most common medical malpractice investigations revolve around:

  • Misdiagnosis or iatrogenesis resulting in patient death
  • Surgery or hospitalization resulting in infection or treatment failures
  • Illegal billing procedures or insurance fraud
  • Medical errors resulting in disability or another injury
  • Rejection of care due to patient’s financial instability
  • Medical negligence in refusing to provide care or providing defective care
  • Negligent prescription treatments leading to addiction or drug contact

Some medical malpractice cases become more sinister if investigators discover that healthcare workers subjected patients to reckless disregard, abusive practices or acted with indecent motivation. These acts are considered so far removed from the accepted standard of care that they are no longer medical malpractice, but criminal.

Common Tasks Involved in Performing Medical Malpractice Investigations

Since the private investigator profession is not closely regulated, their scope of practice is much more limited than an attorney’s. However, there are still many ways that medical malpractice investigators can legally obtain information to prove or disprove a potential claim.

Sponsored Content

Ideally, a client will hire an investigator as soon as medical malpractice is suspected, because:

  • The incident is relatively fresh in the memories of all parties involved.
  • Records and documents of the incident are reasonably current and assessable.
  • There is less time to alter reports or versions of the incident.

Once hired, medical malpractice investigators will attempt to gather as much information about the incident to establish facts. This process usually includes:

  • Collecting client medical records pertaining to the incident in question.
  • Obtaining all other past medical records involving diagnosis and treatment.
  • Researching the healthcare worker’s history of medical malpractice.
  • Interviewing all witnesses that were involved in the incident.
  • Taking witness statements to cement testimonial findings.
  • Researching specific prescription drugs, procedures, and products used during the client’s diagnosis and treatment.
  • Consulting legal experts to determine if any laws were breached.
  • Assembling a team of medical professionals for guidance.
  • Establishing an accurate timeline of events
  • Using surveillance tools to monitor individuals.

Interested in becoming a medical private investigator? Find PI programs near you.

Back to Top